An evaluation of the failure of the paris commune

Paris Commune may be identified as the day long effort that people in the capital made in the spring, to France accepting German military defeat, that ended when the French National Guard retook the city, killing and arresting thousands of Parisians.

An officer or a magistrate whom one elects and whom one controls at all times is already no longer fully an officer or a magistrate. If, as they tell us, "the crisis of society is the crisis of the revolutionary leadership", it is easy to equate the history of the Commune with the history of its leadership.

After the revolutions of failed, a more tough-minded attitude developed 2. Realism may be identified as a cultural trend in Europe during the mids, which rejected the idealism and romanticism of the earlier s in favor of the literary and artistic pictures of life as it really was.

Having learned from the mistakes of the Commune, the Russian Bolsheviks led the workers to a further offensive, not to end until every vestige of the old order had been uprooted and destroyed in the entire country and the working class firmly entrenched.

The Meaning of the Commune Almost every measure taken by the Commune can be explained through an understanding of the deepest daily experiences of the masses.

In both revolutions the threatened classes resorted to bloody repression. French legislative election, February Adolphe Thiersthe chief executive of the French Government during the Commune The national government in Bordeaux called for national elections at the end of January, held just ten days later on 8 February.

The events of 31st October and of 22nd January were but mild foretastes of the new movement underway. A war wrenches the working people out their daily routine.


He reported to the Government that there was no alternative to negotiating an armistice. We must now establish on a firm foundation the society for which the men and women of the Commune fought and died.

Thus from March 18 onwards the class character of the Paris movement, which had previously been pushed into the background by the fight against the foreign invaders, emerged sharply and clearly. While the panicky Mensheviks were muttering the Plekhanov formula, "They should not have resorted to arms," Lenin saw in the heroic struggle of the Moscow workers the revolutionary will to conquer of the Russian working class.

Of the radical and revolutionary groups in Paris at the time of the Commune, the most conservative were the "radical republicans". It becomes the "hierarchic investiture" of which Marx spoke and which is one of the essential features of all class society.

It is carried over, by its own momentum, from wartime into peace time. And a war has to be fought at the same time.

As the Germans surrounded the city, radical groups saw that the Government of National Defence had few soldiers to defend itself, and launched the first demonstrations against it.

Marx, Engels, and Lenin, have studied the Commune closely, and the Russian workers showed that they mastered the lessons of the first proletarian revolution. A resolution was also passed, after a long debate, that the deliberations of the Council were to be secret, since the Commune was effectively at war with the government in Versailles and should not make its intentions known to the enemy.

Before the 18th March, they had declared that, given the unfavourable circumstances, seizing power would be "a desperate folly".


The majority might be described as "left republicans", steeped in idealised nostalgia for the Jacobin regime at the time of the French Revolution.

It also reached a consensus on certain policies that tended towards a progressive, secular, and highly democratic social democracy.

The Commune, Paris 1871

The candidates had only a few days to campaign. Finally, in September, 80, untrained and ill-equipped men were thrown against the great Prussian war machine. Again and again the story has been told: Panic-stricken, he fled from Paris and ordered the army and the civil services to completely evacuate the city and the surrounding forts.

Homes and public buildings were requisitioned for the homeless. They will review the story of the Commune in the light of its achievements as well as of the errors and shortcomings for which the Parisian workers paid so dearly. The Siege and the Commune This was aimed particularly at Pierre Tirardthe republican mayor of the 2nd arrondissement, who had been elected to both Commune and National Assembly.

The chief executive wanted to restore order and national authority in Paris as quickly as possible, and the cannons became a symbol of that authority. Thiers sees the armed workers of Paris as his main obstacle to the conclusion of a peace treaty with Bismarck, and as a potential danger for the whole of bourgeois France.

And the wealthy, many of whom had now returned, stood on the curbs to watch the ghastly parade and congratulate themselves on their victory.

They had helped found the first government of workers; and in revenge the victorious bourgeoisie sent them to die of fever, overwork and inattention, under the tender ministrations of the French foreign troops.

The Prussian forces occupied part of the city for two days, and then withdrew. Why did Engels state that the measures taken by the Communards would, in the last resort, have led "to the abolition of class antagonism between capitalists and workers"? Frustrations of French republicans from revolutionary failures in and 2.

Six demonstrators were killed, and the army cleared the square. These two measures were among the most characteristic taken by the Commune.Alistair Horne's The Fall of Paris: The Siege and the Commune, is the first book of Alistair Horne's trilogy, which includes The Price of Glory and To Lose a Battle and tells the story of the great crises of the rivalry between France and Germany/5.

It looks like you've lost connection to our server. Please check your internet connection or reload this page. The Paris Commune (French: The news arrived the same day of the failure of another attempt by the French army to break the siege of Paris at Bourget, with heavy losses.

On 31 October, the leaders of the main revolutionary groups in Paris, including Blanqui. The Paris Commune is an epoch-making achievement of the revolutionary working class. Marx's tribute at the close of his historic "Address" testifies to the fealty of the world's proletariat to the memory of the valiant Communards and to the cause in behalf of which they fought: "Workingmen's Paris, with its Commune, will be forever celebrated.

The Paris Commune was established by the citizens of Paris in protest against the military surrender at the end of the Franco-Prussian War. It was formally declared on March 28, and successfully governed Paris until May 21, when government troops entered Paris. Failure to prepare adequately for.

of the Paris Commune is presented briefly, but in words so powerful, so incisive, and above all, so true, that there is no equal to it in the whole range of the extensive lit.

An evaluation of the failure of the paris commune
Rated 4/5 based on 90 review